How Appeals & Hearings Work in PA Workers’ Compensation and Social Security Disability

 | News

Reading Time: 4 minutes

When an injury or illness prevents you from working, benefits through Pennsylvania workers’ compensation or Social Security Disability (SSDI) can provide critical financial support. Unfortunately, many claims are denied at the first stage — leaving injured workers and disabled individuals wondering what comes next.

The answer is usually an appeal or a hearing. Understanding how these processes work is key to protecting your rights and getting the benefits you deserve.

Appeals in Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation

If your workers’ comp claim is denied, or if your benefits are cut off, you have the right to appeal. The appeals process typically involves several stages:

1. Filing a Petition

The process begins when you (through your attorney) file a petition with the Pennsylvania Bureau of Workers’ Compensation. This might include petitions for reinstatement of benefits, to challenge a denial, or to modify/terminate benefits.

2. Hearing Before a Workers’ Compensation Judge

Your case will be assigned to a workers’ compensation judge.

  • Both you and your employer/insurance company present evidence.
  • Testimony from you, your employer, doctors, and expert witnesses may be introduced.
  • Judges evaluate medical reports, work records, and legal arguments.

3. Judge’s Decision

The judge issues a written decision. If the ruling is unfavorable, you may appeal further.

4. Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board

You can appeal a judge’s decision to the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board (WCAB). The Board reviews the record and arguments but does not take new evidence.

5. Commonwealth Court & PA Supreme Court

If needed, appeals can go to the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania and even the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.

⚖️ Tip: These appeals are highly technical. Legal representation is crucial for navigating deadlines, presenting strong evidence, and understanding case law.

Hearings in Social Security Disability (SSDI)

Many Social Security Disability claims are denied at the initial level.

1. Reconsideration

After an initial denial, you can often request reconsideration. A different examiner reviews your case and any new evidence. Many claims are still denied at this stage.

2. Requesting a Hearing

The next step is requesting a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). This is often the first real opportunity to present your case in detail.

3. The Hearing Process

At the hearing, the ALJ will:

  • Review your medical records and work history.
  • Ask questions about your symptoms and limitations.
  • Usually bring in a vocational expert to testify about your ability to work.

Your attorney can question witnesses, cross-examine experts, and make legal arguments on your behalf.

4. National Hearing Centers & Online Options

In recent years, the Social Security Administration has expanded National Hearing Centers and video hearings. This helps reduce backlogs and allows claimants to attend hearings remotely — but it also requires careful preparation to ensure your evidence is presented clearly.

5. Appeals Council & Federal Court

If you lose at the ALJ stage, you can appeal to the Social Security Appeals Council and, ultimately, to federal court.

Common Challenges Workers Face in Appeals & Hearings

  • Delays: Hearings can take months or even over a year to be scheduled.
  • Complex Rules: Each stage has strict deadlines and evidentiary rules.
  • Medical Evidence: Many denials are based on a lack of “objective medical evidence.” Gathering strong documentation is essential.
  • Employer/Insurer Pushback: In workers’ comp, employers often fight to minimize benefits or deny claims outright.
  • Navigating Online Hearings: While convenient, remote hearings can be intimidating without proper preparation.

Why Legal Representation Matters

Both workers’ comp and SSDI appeals are stacked against claimants at first. Having an attorney can make the difference by:

  • Meeting strict filing deadlines.
  • Preparing persuasive evidence and witness testimony.
  • Cross-examining employer doctors or vocational experts.
  • Framing your case in a way that meets the legal standard for benefits.

Final Thoughts

If your workers’ compensation or Social Security Disability claim has been denied, don’t give up. Denials are common, but the appeals and hearing processes exist to give you another chance at justice.

With an experienced attorney guiding you, you can navigate the system, build a stronger case, and fight for the benefits you need to move forward.